White house exterior clad in horizontal lap siding with balconies and greenery
Photo: Büşranur Aydın / Pexels
Quote check guide

Is My Siding Quote Too High?

Quick answer Estimate
Over $15,000 is high

To re-side 1,250 sq ft of wall in vinyl, our range is $7,200–$15,000, typically $10,000 ($5.75–$12.00 per sq ft). A quote above about $15,000 is high for that job at U.S. average prices, and above about $19,000 it's very high, unless it includes tearing off the old siding, new sheathing, insulation, upper stories or a pricier material such as fiber cement.

It's our blend of three published sources[1][2][3]. Wall area is usually on the quote in squares; check your size and city with the quote checker.

What a normal siding quote looks like

Siding is priced per square foot of wall covered, not per square foot of house, and contractors often quote in "squares" of 100 sq ft. These ranges are for 1,250 sq ft of wall, the size the Cost vs. Value report prices, before tearing off the old siding.

Siding quote ranges by material, 1,250 sq ft of wall
Material, 1,250 sq ft of wallNormal range Typical Very high above
Vinyl$7,200 – $15,000$10,000$19,000+
Fiber cement$9,700 – $18,100$13,100$22,500+
Wood or cedar$8,100 – $17,500$11,900$22,000+
Steel$9,700 – $18,800$13,400$23,500+

The normal range and typical come straight from our siding replacement cost guide. "Very high" means 25% above our high end, the same rule the quote checker uses. These are U.S. average prices, so adjust for your area below.

What the sources say

HomeGuide puts most siding jobs at $4 to $13 per sq ft installed.[1] Angi's 2026 average siding project is $11,589, with most between $5,554 and $17,720.[2] The 2025 Cost vs. Value report prices replacing 1,250 sq ft at $17,950 in vinyl and $21,485 in factory-finished fiber cement, trim included.[3] The benchmark runs higher because it's a fully specified job with new trim at every opening.

Example: is $18,000 too much for vinyl siding?

For 1,250 sq ft of vinyl siding at U.S. average prices, our checker says: High. An $18,000 quote is 20% above the high end of our range ($15,000). HomeGuide puts tear-off at $0.70 to $2.00 per sq ft, roughly $900–$2,500 on this house,[1] which still leaves it above our range. For fiber cement, $18,000 is inside our $9,700–$18,100 range, 37% above our typical $13,100.

Why siding quotes run high

  • Stories and staging. Second and third stories need scaffolding or pump jacks and slower, safer work. Steep grades and tight side yards add setup time.
  • Corners, gables and trim. Every outside corner, window, door and vent needs trim and careful cutting, so a house with dormers and bump-outs costs more per foot than a plain box.
  • Tear-off and sheathing. HomeGuide puts tear-off at $0.70 to $2.00 per sq ft.[1] Soft sheathing or missing flashing found underneath is extra, so ask for a per-sheet repair price.
  • Insulation. Adding rigid foam or insulated siding is cheapest during a re-side. HomeGuide puts insulation at $1.00 to $4.50 per sq ft.[1]
  • Permit. HomeGuide puts siding permits at $30 to $200[1] and Angi at $150 to $1,500.[2]
  • Location. Labor costs differ by region; see the table below.

What to do if your quote looks high

  1. Check the wall area. Ask how many squares the bid covers (squares × 100 = sq ft of wall), then use the quote checker with that size and your metro.
  2. Ask for an itemized bid with tear-off, sheathing repairs (per sheet), housewrap, trim, flashing, permit and disposal listed separately.
  3. Get two more bids on the same written scope and compare them line by line. Our guide to comparing contractor bids shows how.
  4. Hold a contingency. Sheathing and flashing repairs are the usual surprise; our siding guide suggests setting aside 10%. The contingency calculator can help.

Regional differences

We don't republish regional price tables. Our exterior cost index for each Census division, built from six exterior projects, is applied here to our typical vinyl job.

See the full table
Our exterior cost index and typical vinyl siding cost by division
Region (Census division)Our cost index Typical vinyl, 1,250 sq ft
New England
CT, ME, MA, NH, RI, VT
1.02
2% above U.S.
$10,200
Middle Atlantic
NJ, NY, PA
1.15
15% above U.S.
$11,500
South Atlantic
DE, DC, FL, GA, MD, NC, SC, VA, WV
0.96
4% below U.S.
$9,600
U.S. average1.00$10,000
East North Central
IL, IN, MI, OH, WI
1.01
1% above U.S.
$10,100
East South Central
AL, KY, MS, TN
0.90
10% below U.S.
$9,000
West North Central
IA, KS, MN, MO, NE, ND, SD
1.01
1% above U.S.
$10,100
West South Central
AR, LA, OK, TX
0.91
9% below U.S.
$9,100
Mountain
AZ, CO, ID, MT, NV, NM, UT, WY
0.97
3% below U.S.
$9,700
Pacific
AK, CA, HI, OR, WA
1.05
5% above U.S.
$10,500
How we adjust for each region

We worked these out ourselves; they aren't published figures. For each region, we look at how far its 2025 Cost vs. Value prices for six exterior projects (vinyl and fiber-cement siding, vinyl and wood windows, wood and composite decks) sit above or below the national average, then average the six results.[3] The typical column applies that to our national typical. Our method is in How we build our ranges.

Costs in your city

Where you live changes the price, mostly because of labor. Our local cost pages adjust these national ranges for 50 metro areas using local construction wages, including Columbus, Minneapolis and San Diego. See all 50 cities →

Siding quote FAQ

Is $18,000 too much for vinyl siding?

For 1,250 sq ft of wall, it's above our $7,200–$15,000 range at U.S. average prices. It can be fair for a larger or taller house, a job with tear-off and new sheathing, fiber cement or a high-cost area.

How much should new siding cost?

Typically about $8.00 per sq ft of wall for vinyl and $10.50 for fiber cement by our blended ranges, or about $10,000 and $13,100 for 1,250 sq ft.[1][2][3]

How do I know how much wall my quote covers?

Look for squares on the quote; one square is 100 sq ft of wall. To check it, multiply each wall's length by its height, add the gables and subtract big openings such as garage doors.

Why are siding quotes so different?

Bids can price different siding lines, trim, housewrap and how much sheathing they expect to replace, and some include tear-off while others don't. Compare them line by line.

Can new siding go over the old siding?

Sometimes, if the old siding is flat, tight and sound. HomeGuide notes that most reputable contractors won't do it, because hidden rot can spread under the new layer.[1]

Sources

  1. HomeGuide, “How much does house siding cost to install or replace?” (updated Oct 29, 2025). homeguide.com/costs/siding-cost (accessed Oct 8, 2026).
  2. Angi, “How Much Does It Cost to Replace or Install Siding? [2026 Data]” (updated Aug 3, 2026). angi.com/articles/how-much-does-it-cost-replace-siding.htm (accessed Oct 8, 2026).
  3. Zonda / Journal of Light Construction, 2025 Cost vs. Value Report: national averages, project descriptions for vinyl and fiber-cement siding replacement and regional pages (New England, Middle Atlantic, South Atlantic, East North Central, East South Central, West North Central, West South Central, Mountain, Pacific) (accessed Oct 8, 2026). © 2025 Zonda Media. We quote a few national figures and use the regional figures only to derive our own cost index. States per division from the U.S. Census Bureau, Census Regions and Divisions.
  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS), May 2025 national median hourly wages by occupation, retrieved through the BLS Public Data API. bls.gov/oes (accessed Oct 8, 2026).

Figures with a citation number are quoted straight from the sources above. Everything else is our own math on top of them, and How we build our ranges shows how we did it. These are numbers to plan with, not quotes, so get itemized bids from local contractors before you commit.